The cancellation forces Ibiza Town Council to rethink the procurement of an essential beach safety service after shortcomings in the tender documents were challenged by the Balearic Islands’ Lifesaving and Rescue Companies Association.

Ibiza Town Council has cancelled the tender for lifeguard, rescue and beach surveillance services across the municipality, involving a contract worth €1,446,472 over two years, with the option of extending it for a further two. Spain’s Central Administrative Court for Contractual Appeals (TACRC) has partially upheld an appeal filed by the Balearic Islands’ Lifesaving and Rescue Companies Association against the terms of the tender covering the 2026–2029 period.

The cancellation was formalised on 3 November through a decree signed by Deputy Mayor Gema Marí Planells, following the court’s ruling of 22 October. The council declared the entire procurement process void and closed the case, concluding that the shortcomings in the tender documents could not be corrected without changing the conditions governing competition between bidders.

A council spokesperson offered a more nuanced interpretation of the ruling, stressing that “the Court did not question the service itself or the tender as a whole”. The spokesperson said the court had upheld the challenged award criteria and the general system of penalties, while requiring certain special performance conditions to be clarified and the calculation basis for penalties to be specified.

The council also pointed out that it had already amended the weighting of the quality criteria before the ruling was issued, meaning the court considered that particular complaint no longer relevant.

The contract was intended to cover three of Ibiza’s main beach areas: Talamanca, Figueretes and Platja d’en Bossa. The tender was published on 29 March, and the business association lodged its appeal against the contract documents on 13 April.

The council amended some of the conditions ten days later. However, on 30 April, the court ordered the provisional suspension of the tender, citing the possibility of damage that could be difficult or impossible to reverse if the process continued. The suspension was lifted with the court’s ruling on 22 October, and the council formally cancelled the tender on 3 November.

How Ibiza Maintained Beach Lifeguard Services During the Summer

Following questions from Diario de Ibiza about how the service was provided last summer, the council explained that it kept the existing lifeguard company in place while the appeal was being resolved.

According to the local authority, this arrangement was necessary because lifeguard services are essential to beachgoers’ safety and “could not be interrupted”.

The council added that the decision also allowed it to retain the same team of lifeguards. It noted that, in any case, the staff would have continued working under the new contract because of the employee transfer obligations included in the original tender documents.

Regarding payments, the council spokesperson stated that “the services actually provided have been paid for following the submission of the corresponding invoices”. These payments were subsequently submitted for approval by the municipal plenary council through the procedure known as omission of the comptroller’s prior review.

This administrative procedure is used when expenditure has not undergone the prior financial oversight that would normally be required from the municipal controller’s office.

What Went Wrong With the Ibiza Beach Lifeguard Tender?

The TACRC’s 26-page ruling identified several shortcomings in the tender documents, particularly concerning the lack of clarity surrounding employment obligations.

These included provisions relating to wages, occupational risk prevention and the transfer of information about employees who would have to be retained by the incoming contractor under Spain’s employee subrogation rules.

The court found that some clauses were so broadly worded that companies bidding for the contract could not clearly establish which commitments they would be expected to assume.

It also identified problems with the provisions on disability and gender equality.

The court rejected the inclusion of a general requirement to have an equality plan as a special performance condition for companies already legally obliged to maintain one. It also considered the provision giving preference to hiring women in certain circumstances too vague.

Another issue concerned a data protection clause that had been classified as an essential contractual obligation, despite the tender documents stating that the contract did not involve the transfer or processing of personal data.

The court also required the council to correct the way contractual penalties were calculated. These should be based on the annual contract award price, rather than the annual budget allocated to the service.

Ibiza’s 2026 Budget Increases Spending on Beach Services

Ibiza Town Council’s 2026 municipal budget allocates €869,589 to services provided by external companies on the municipality’s beaches, compared with €650,000 in 2025. This represents an increase of 33.8%.

However, the budget does not specify how much of this allocation is earmarked specifically for lifeguard and rescue services, meaning the entire increase cannot be attributed to that contract.

As for the next steps, the council spokesperson confirmed that the local authority is currently adapting the tender documents to comply with the court’s ruling.

“Once the procedure has been resolved, a new tender will be processed,” the spokesperson said.

The council has not yet announced when the new procurement process will be launched, nor has it disclosed the cost of maintaining the lifeguard service throughout the summer of 2026.